To content
Neuroscience & Ethics

How to Test Whether Brain Organoids Possess Consciousness

-
in
  • Research Alliance Ruhr
  • UA Ruhr
  • Research
© Katja Marquard ​/​ Ruhr-Universität Bochum
Lucia Melloni is a member of the Research Center One Health Ruhr.
No one can ask a cluster of cells in a Petri dish what it’s thinking or even feeling. Nevertheless, it is possible to test whether it possesses a mind, says Lucia Melloni of the Research Center One Health Ruhr.

The development of brain organoids is advancing at a rapid pace. Researchers are creating tiny clusters of cells in the laboratory that behave like sections of the human brain. The extent to which such organoids could develop intelligence or even consciousness is a matter of debate. Prof. Dr. Lucia Melloni of Ruhr University Bochum and Prof. Dr. Stanislas Dehaene of the Collège de France in Paris propose an experimental framework that could help us get closer to an answer. Their article appeared in a special issue of the journal *Neuron* on brain organoids on November 11, 2026.

“At present, I do not believe that brain organoids possess consciousness,” says Lucia Melloni, who conducts research at Ruhr University Bochum and at the Research Center One Health Ruhr of the University Alliance Ruhr. “But given how rapidly the technology is advancing, it’s conceivable in the future. That’s why we should start thinking now about how we can test it.” Melloni and Dehaene have developed an experimental approach specifically for this purpose.

The Bochum-based neuroscientist expects groundbreaking findings from organoid research in the future. Together with colleagues, she is advocating for an international committee to regulate research on organoids. “The goal must be to gain new insights in an ethically responsible manner—and to do so with the involvement of society,” says Melloni. A first step toward fostering dialogue with all relevant stakeholders has already been taken: at the 2025 Asilomar Conference in California, which Lucia Melloni attended.

Ruhr Innovation Lab
The Ruhr Innovation Lab—a consortium comprising Ruhr University Bochum and TU Dortmund University, which will receive funding as a Center of Excellence starting January 1, 2027—also pursues precisely this approach of involving all relevant stakeholders. Melloni is a member of the “The Healthy Mind in a Complex World” research area at the Ruhr Innovation Lab.